Re: [faq-maintainers] Re: RFC violations of this list software

---------

Peter_Kappesser@promail.com
Tue, 18 Aug 1998 03:08:37 -0400


Andrew Gierth <andrew@erlenstar.demon.co.uk> writes:
> Received: from 157.22.240.7 by lists.consensus.com (Lyris SMTP service); 16 Aug 98 11:24:12 PDT7 from:<pogo@qz.little-neck.ny.us> to:<FAQ-Maintainers@lists.consensus.com>
> That received header violates RFC 822. Received: has a specific
> syntax, it is not a free-form header; and all that crud added on the
> end after the timestamp is in violation of that syntax.
>
> [following line munged to confuse Lyris]
> Message-1d: &gt;LYR953-91--andrew<AT>erlenstar.demon.co.uk&lt;
> That message-ID violates RFC 822, because the generating host cannot
> guarantee its uniqueness. *NO-ONE* other than my machine should be
> generating message-ids ending in @erlenstar.demon.co.uk>.

On 8/16/98, Tom Lane wrote:
> Not only is it against RFC specs, but it's a good way to get the list
> traffic sent to /dev/null by anyone who's using spam filtering. There
> are a fair number of spammers using engines that put the victim's
> address into the Message-ID. As a result, a lot of people (including
> me) filter against Message-IDs like that. I've had to fish all of
> today's traffic out of a "probable spam" folder.
>
> Why in the world is this listserv generating a new Message-ID for each
> recipient, anyway? It'd make a lot more sense to preserve the original
> Message-ID, IMHO.

Preserving the original Message-ID also allows me to filter duplicate
messages from folks who cc: me directly as well as posting to the list
-- which works fine for every other list I'm on.

In short, the software is defective and the listadmin should replace
this "upgrade" with something that works properly.

--
Watch "Babylon 5" weeknights at 7pm (ET) on TNT!
Peter_Kappesser@promail.com


[ Usenet Hypertext FAQ Archive | Search Mail Archive | Authors | Usenet ]
[ 1993 | 1994 | 1995 | 1996 | 1997 ]

---------

faq-admin@faqs.org

© Copyright The Internet FAQ Consortium, 1997
All rights reserved