|
Top Document: soc.culture.jewish FAQ: Torah and Halachic Authority (3/12) Previous Document: Question 4.1: What is "Halacha?" How is it determined? Next Document: Question 4.3: Traditionally, what are the different rabbinic eras? See reader questions & answers on this topic! - Help others by sharing your knowledge
Answer:
1. Minhag. Custom. Custom, although not really part of Halachah, can
change. Minhag is any act that the masses, on their own, accept.
Any minhag that is against actual Halachah, is called a minhag
ta'os, a mistaken minhag. Any that is based on a misunderstanding
is a minhag shtus, a foolish custom. These two should not be
followed. Any nearly universal minhag is called a Minhag Yisroel,
and has most of the stringencies of law. (Yarmulka, and Ma'ariv
services are two examples of a Minhag Yisroel.)
2. Din dirabanan. A rabbinic law. These are set up by the rabbinate,
instead of the masses, in order to preserve the spirit of the law.
For example, Purim and Chanukah. There are 7 new commandments that
are entirely rabbinic, bringing the famous total of 613 mitzvot up
to 620.
3. Gezeira dirabanan. A rabbinic "fence". These are enacted to
prevent a common cause for breaking the act of the law. For
example, one may not place food directly on a fire before Shabbat
in order to keep it heated during Shabbat. This is a fence around
the law against cooking on Shabbat. To prevent the gezeira from
being violated, a metal cover, called a blech in Yiddish, is
placed on the stove top before Shabbat with the flame (turned to a
low setting) under one section and the pot with food placed on the
blech. This blech serves as a fence, allowing heating of the food
without any danger of violating the law. Note that a "gezeira
dirabanan" becomes binding only if it is accepted by the
community.
4. P'sak. A rabbinic ruling. This ruling addresses a the questionable
area of some law or custom. A p'sak can only be over ruled by
another body which is both larger in number, and greater in
"chochmah". (The ability to know how to use the facts. Not more
knowledgeable book-wise, but more steeped in the Torah
weltanschauung.)
The distinction between the second and third categories is subtle. In
order to be a Din (or Issur, or Melachah) Dirabanan, the prohibited
action must be similar in purpose to the permitted one. A gezeira does
not even require an action. In the example I gave, it was inaction,
leaving the pot where it is, that is prohibited. The category includes
things that are similar in means to the prohibited act, and will
therefore cause confusion about what is and what isn't okay; and
things which will allow people to be caught up in habit, and forget
about the prohibition. Only a gezeira may defy an actual Divine law
(although a p'sak will often define one), and even so only under
specific circumstances. All of the following must be satisfied:
* The law being protected is more stringent than the one being
violated. This determination isn't easy.
* The law is being violated only through inaction. No one is being
told to actively violate G-d's commandment.
* The law being violated will still be applicable in most
situations. It still must exist in some form.
On the other hand, a gezeira is less powerful than a normal rabbinic
law in that they can not be compounded. One may not make a "fence" for
the express purpose of protecting another "fence". A law is considered
accepted if it becomes common practice. Any din or gezeira which does
not get accepted by the masses in the short run, does not become
binding in the long run. Similarly, there are rules for p'sak, but
they are violated if the masses choose to follows some other rabbinic
body's p'sak. Notice, however, that this is only in the short run.
Once a law is accepted, it may only be overruled by p'sak. It cannot
just fade into non-practice.
User Contributions:Top Document: soc.culture.jewish FAQ: Torah and Halachic Authority (3/12) Previous Document: Question 4.1: What is "Halacha?" How is it determined? Next Document: Question 4.3: Traditionally, what are the different rabbinic eras? Single Page [ Usenet FAQs | Web FAQs | Documents | RFC Index ] Send corrections/additions to the FAQ Maintainer: SCJ FAQ Maintainer <maintainer@scjfaq.org>
Last Update March 27 2014 @ 02:11 PM
|

Comment about this article, ask questions, or add new information about this topic: