Re: Improving efficiency of *.answers moderation process

---------

Robert F. Heeter (rfheeter@pppl.gov)
Thu, 6 Oct 1994 19:28:09 -0800


>>> Just to correct one misunderstanding here: when the moderators do
>>> approve your posting, they will *not* post it for you. They just send
>>> you mail telling you it's OK for you to start posting into news.answers.
>> ...
>> the implication of their asking you to
>> submit the FAQ by posting it is that if they approve it, it will be posted,
>> just as other moderated newsgroups work. (Is that mistaken?)
>
>Quite. Wasn't I clear enough for you? The moderators will NOT repost
>that article. It will never appear anywhere except in their inbox.
>In fact, they don't ever repost ANY articles.

No, you weren't. I didn't realize that a moderator has to repost an article.
I was under the impression that an article simply picked up an appropriate
header and then became "posted", so that moderators don't repost anything.
In other words, I thought that if I submitted something to a moderated
newsgroup (like *.answers), moderator approval did not require that the
moderator repost the article. I agree that making the moderators post
something *for* you is needless, but I didn't understand that that's
how moderation *worked*.

I figured this out from the other replies about a week ago; for some
reason this particular message was held up for over a week by mit.edu.

Sorry to appear to be beating a dead horse here.

>PS to moderators: evidently the section of the intro documents covering
>this stuff is still not clear enough. I realize that you are loathe to
>explain the approval-forgery bit in publicly posted documents, but perhaps
>you could find the time to go over those paragraphs again...

I second this; There will be misunderstandings about how it works,
unless you explain it more clearly.

In a separate message I've suggested a way of doing this which doesn't
make "approval-forgery" a blatantly obvious concept, while still providing
an FAQ maintainer with the appropriate information about the process.

*************************************************
Robert F. Heeter, rfheeter@pppl.gov
Graduate Student, Princeton University Plasma Physics Lab
Conventional Fusion FAQ maintainer.



[ Usenet Hypertext FAQ Archive | Search Mail Archive | Authors | Usenet ]
[ 1993 | 1994 | 1995 | 1996 | 1997 ]

---------

faq-admin@landfield.com

© Copyright The Landfield Group, 1997
All rights reserved