background image
In ascending stairwell B, firefighters were passing a steady and heavy stream
of descending civilians. Firemen were impressed with the composure and total
lack of panic shown by almost all civilians. Many civilians were in awe of the
firefighters and found their mere presence to be calming.
113
Firefighters periodically stopped on particular floors and searched to ensure
that no civilians were still on it. In a few instances healthy civilians were found
on floors, either because they still were collecting personal items or for no
apparent reason; they were told to evacuate immediately. Firefighters deputized
healthy civilians to be in charge of others who were struggling or injured.
114
Climbing up the stairs with heavy protective clothing and equipment was
hard work even for physically fit firefighters.As firefighters began to suffer vary-
ing levels of fatigue, some became separated from others in their unit.
115
At 9:32, a senior chief radioed all units in the North Tower to return to the
lobby, either because of a false report of a third plane approaching or because
of his judgment about the deteriorating condition of the building. Once the
rumor of the third plane was debunked, other chiefs continued operations, and
there is no evidence that any units actually returned to the lobby. At the same
time, a chief in the lobby was asked to consider the possibility of a rooftop res-
cue but was unable to reach FDNY dispatch by radio or phone. Out on West
Street, however, the FDNY Chief of Department had already dismissed any
rooftop rescue as impossible.
116
As units climbed higher, their ability to communicate with chiefs on tacti-
cal 1 became more limited and sporadic, both because of the limited effective-
ness of FDNY radios in high-rises and because so many units on tactical 1 were
trying to communicate at once. When attempting to reach a particular unit,
chiefs in the lobby often heard nothing in response.
117
Just prior to 10:00, in the North Tower one engine company had climbed
to the 54th floor, at least two other companies of firefighters had reached the
sky lobby on the 44th floor, and numerous units were located between the 5th
and 37th floors.
118
FDNY South Tower and Marriott Hotel Operations.
Immediately after
the repeater test, a senior chief and a battalion chief commenced operations in
the South Tower lobby. Almost at once they were joined by an OEM field
responder.They were not, however, joined right away by a sizable number of
fire companies, as units that had been in or en route to the North Tower lobby
at 9:03 were not reallocated to the South Tower.
119
A battalion chief and a ladder company found a working elevator to the 40th
floor and from there proceeded to climb stairwell B.Another ladder company
arrived soon thereafter, and began to rescue civilians trapped in an elevator
between the first and second floors. The senior chief in the lobby expressed
frustration about the lack of units he initially had at his disposal for South Tower
operations.
120
Unlike the commanders in the North Tower, the senior chief in the lobby
HEROISM AND HORROR
299
Final 8-9.5pp 7/17/04 1:24 PM Page 299