| Player | Year from | Year to |
|---|---|---|
| McClure Hal | 1874 | 1877 |
| Rhines Billy | 1888 | 1889 |
| Smith Harvey | 1891 | 1894 |
| Mathewson Christy | 1899 | 1901 |
| Doolan Mickey | 1899 | 1904 |
| Veil Bucky | 1900 | 1902 |
| McCormick Moose | 1900 | 1903 |
| Sebring Jimmy | 1901 | 1901 |
| Blair Walter | 1903 | 1907 |
| Parson Jiggs | 1904 | 1909 |
| Mathewson Henry | 1905 | 1906 |
| Kauffman Dick | 1907 | 1907 |
| Northrop Jake | 1907 | 1910 |
| Clark Jim | 1907 | 1911 |
| Daniels Bert | 1910 | 1910 |
| Piez Sandy | 1910 | 1913 |
| Wyckoff Weldon | 1911 | 1912 |
| Sturgis Dean | 1911 | 1913 |
| Buzas Joe | 1938 | 1941 |
| Keegan Bob | 1940 | 1943 |
| Upton Tom | 1943 | 1945 |
| Junge Eric | 1996 | 1999 |