| Player | Year from | Year to |
|---|---|---|
| Stratton Asa | 1871 | 1871 |
| Salisbury Harry | 1877 | 1879 |
| Richmond Lee | 1877 | 1879 |
| Tenney Fred | 1877 | 1880 |
| White Bill | 1879 | 1883 |
| Bassett Charley | 1883 | 1884 |
| Clarke Artie | 1884 | 1886 |
| Dowd Tommy | 1888 | 1890 |
| Tenney Fred | 1890 | 1894 |
| Woodcock Fred | 1891 | 1891 |
| Sexton Frank | 1891 | 1893 |
| Steere Gene | 1891 | 1894 |
| Clark Roy | 1893 | 1897 |
| Lauder Billy | 1893 | 1898 |
| Mellor Bill | 1893 | 1899 |
| Washburn Libe | 1893 | 1901 |
| Fultz Dave | 1894 | 1898 |
| Gammons Daff | 1895 | 1898 |
| Lynch Mike | 1899 | 1904 |
| Pattee Harry | 1901 | 1906 |
| Tift Ray | 1903 | 1907 |
| Nourse Chet | 1906 | 1909 |
| Nash Ken | 1907 | 1912 |
| Warner Ed | 1908 | 1912 |
| Snell Wally | 1908 | 1913 |
| Eayrs Eddie | 1909 | 1913 |
| Conzelman Joe | 1910 | 1912 |
| Crowell Cap | 1911 | 1915 |
| Murray Bill | 1912 | 1917 |
| Babington Charlie | 1913 | 1915 |
| Davidson Claude | 1915 | 1917 |
| Merewether Art | 1920 | 1922 |
| Neubauer Hal | 1921 | 1925 |
| Hadley Bump | 1924 | 1925 |
| Caldwell Bruce | 1924 | 1926 |
| Billings Josh | 1927 | 1927 |
| Murray Amby | 1934 | 1936 |
| Almon Bill | 1973 | 1974 |