| Player | Year from | Year to |
|---|---|---|
| Stratton Asa | 1874 | 1875 |
| Sullivan Denny | 1875 | 1877 |
| Dignan Steve | 1878 | 1880 |
| Gunning Tom | 1881 | 1884 |
| Ryan Jimmy | 1881 | 1885 |
| Slattery Jack | 1896 | 1901 |
| Hart Hub | 1898 | 1901 |
| Stankard Tom | 1901 | 1904 |
| Strobel Allie | 1902 | 1905 |
| Maloney Charlie | 1905 | 1908 |
| Casey Joe | 1906 | 1909 |
| Harrington Andy | 1908 | 1913 |
| Whelan Tom | 1913 | 1920 |
| Urban Luke | 1917 | 1921 |
| Kamp Ike | 1919 | 1924 |
| Phillips Eddie | 1920 | 1923 |
| Wilson Frank | 1921 | 1924 |
| Vargus Bill | 1921 | 1925 |
| Moncewicz Freddie | 1922 | 1928 |
| Shea John | 1923 | 1928 |
| McNamara Dinny | 1924 | 1927 |
| Weston Al | 1924 | 1929 |
| Creeden Pat | 1925 | 1930 |
| Spognardi Andy | 1928 | 1932 |
| Gallagher Ed | 1929 | 1932 |
| McLaughlin Jud | 1930 | 1931 |
| Roy Emil | 1930 | 1933 |
| Pellagrini Eddie | 1937 | 1938 |
| Waitkus Eddie | 1938 | 1938 |
| DeKoning Bill | 1938 | 1941 |
| Merullo Lennie | 1939 | 1939 |
| Coleman Joe | 1940 | 1940 |
| Roarke Mike | 1949 | 1952 |
| Morgan Joe | 1950 | 1952 |
| Looney Brian | 1989 | 1991 |